RPM pickup problem

This forum is for discussing ignition setup, tuning, and troubleshooting for MicroSquirt (TM)
Forum rules
Read the manual to see if your question is answered there before posting. If you have questions about MS1/Extra or MS2/Extra or other non-B&G code configuration or tuning, please post them at http://www.msextra.com The full forum rules are here: Forum Rules, be sure to read them all regularly.
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

Hi !

Project is Suzuki VS 1400 with microsquirt controlling fuel and spark. Problem is that I get inconsistent RPM reading while cranking. See pictures. Bike has pickup coil for each cylinder. Looked the signal with oscilloscope and it seems to be Ok ? I have tried resistors in series with coils.. No help at all

Image

Image
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

Might the problem be too long theet at the flywheel ? Any solution or do I have to modify the tooth ?
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

Image
dontz125
Master Squirter
Posts: 375
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:00 pm
Contact:

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by dontz125 »

Yup - THAT's a long tooth! Unfortunately, while the bike OEMs love their long teeth with edge-detector circuits, the MS family is built around short teeth and zero-crossing detection. Zero-crossing is more accurate and repeatable at all RPMs, but is simply unable to deal properly with a long tooth.
VR_teeth_mismatched.jpg
(51.97 KiB) Not downloaded yet
You'll need to either switch to a Hall / 'geartooth' sensor, or add an edge-detection filter circuit.
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

Thank for your response.

So think I should cut the tooth ? is ~8mm long in right range `?
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

It´s odd firing T-twin with pickups for both cylinders. I´m using the dualspark mode.
Maick1
MegaSquirt Newbie
Posts: 11
Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:33 am

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by Maick1 »

Problem solved by adding 2x470k ohm resistors in series with the pickup coils. Cranking rpm stays at steady 230-233 rpm. Tomorrow have to try start-up.

Flywheel theet staid intact.
24c
Master Squirter
Posts: 593
Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 12:15 pm
Location: Chorley, Lancashire UK
Contact:

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by 24c »

Congrats on solving your problem, but just a FYI for others, and that pesky long tooth problem.

I haven't got a long tooth flywheel to test, but I was experimenting with an Opel aka Vauxhall (GM) crank sensor a few weeks ago. It's Hall effect, 12V+, GND & 8V out BUT it's directional, which means if I rotate the sensor, I would see two trigger events for a "long tooth", but if I turn it through 180 degrees I only see one. Admittedly my "long tooth" is only 6 & 12mm long on my test rig at the moment, but it might be useful info for others in converting a long tooth flywheel. Opel part number is 9174621, and you can get them on fleaBay cheap enough. Their performance is excellent, I can trigger at 7 rpm on a 100mm diameter wheel with another make of programmable ignition. (Not using the MicroSquirt on this engine, as it only needs ignition...twin plugged flat twin)
dontz125
Master Squirter
Posts: 375
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:00 pm
Contact:

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by dontz125 »

Maick1 - is that 1x 470k resistor per coil, or 2 per coil? I'm absolutely fascinated by this; long teeth have been the bugbear of people trying to run uS and MS ignitions on stock bike trigger wheels for years, and I'm simply astonished that such a TRIVIAL modification is bringing what appears to be success. I await full-speed tests with slack-jawed hope!

24c - from what I gather, that's pretty much typical performance of any gear-tooth sensor, but still pretty good! Unfortunately that sensor is fairly large for a simple swap-in for OEM VR sensors - car VRs are big and clunky; bike VR sensors tend to be ... compact. Also, you listed your pinout as +12v, GND - and EIGHT volts output?
24c
Master Squirter
Posts: 593
Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 12:15 pm
Location: Chorley, Lancashire UK
Contact:

Re: RPM pickup problem

Post by 24c »

dontz125 wrote:Unfortunately that sensor is fairly large for a simple swap-in for OEM VR sensors - car VRs are big and clunky; bike VR sensors tend to be ... compact. Also, you listed your pinout as +12v, GND - and EIGHT volts output?
Hi buddy, just seen this, been dormant a while, but as I am playing with EFI again and using this sensor, thought I'd update the post!
Yep, I got the pinouts wrong, #1=8V (supposedly, but I've hooked it up to 12V too, no issues to date), #2 = output , and #3 = GND. Sensor is able to go in my bike heads with stepped adaptor bush, size wise its 25mm above the surface 24 below, and needs a Ø20mm bore to seal & comes with 500mm lead and 3 pin male JPT plug.

Interestingly, I struggled to get this Hall sensor to work this time, using the official useasydocs suggested layout, on a MicroSquirt v2 "Dual Tach Inputs". In the end, to get reliable start up performance, from 40 - 8000 rpm, I used the following connections.

Sensor 2 Output = VR2IN+
Sensor 1 Output = OPTOIN-
+5V (Vref) = OPTOIN+

Might help somebody else, but I'm wondering if this is a settings issue & some other combos might work too.

The v3 was a little harder, which again was surprising, as it worked great with the twin VR set up previously, so I thought it'd be a walk in the park with Hall sensors. Daft bit was I hadn't found the latest useasydocs document info, so I was forced to look at the MAX9926 data sheet and try and understand what was happening. :oops:
This latest update, link here was spot on, and BTW, I did use a pull up resistor referenced to Vref too :)

Happy holidays to you all, & glad the website is back.
Mike
Post Reply